Month: March 2015

Lance’s Crusade

Lance was desperate.  There was no denying it.  But then again, maybe he COULD go on denying it!?  He had not precisely made up his mind about whether or not he would go on trying to conceal his creatureliness, but for the moment he had determined to go to the meeting.  Of course there was no escaping the fact that he was nervous …he was downright terrified!  His entire life’s work was on the line!  He had as of late come to realize that his life’s work was far more meager than he ever dared to consider, but it was ‘HIS life’s work’ nonetheless.  HIS ideas, HIS designs, HIS schemes, HIS cherished cravings permeated every scintilla of the work.  All of his deepest, most dearly-held sentiments were wed to the work.  And therefore, though he was hardly aware of it – for his head was not entirely clear – he had resolved to carry a concealed conspiracy into the meeting.  As a matter of protocol he would enlist with the requisite contrition, and he would make a deliberate effort to strike a pose of destitution …but the simultaneous subterfuge would also be present, and ultimately his pernicious pride would prevail.

Lance arrived at the meeting and enrolled himself in the guild – attempting to look as modest as possible.  Part of him actually wanted this posture of humility to be authentic, but he found the work of subjugating his proud whims and feelings maddening, and ultimately, he found it quite impossible to manufacture even the smallest smidgen of genuine modesty.  The meeting was not necessarily what he expected it to be.  There were both peripheral details as well as matters of primary substance that he didn’t expect.  But when all was said and done – the demands of desperate dependence were the focal point (that most indispensable step of self-denial refused to recede).  This is what Lance feared most of all.  His desperation was undeniable, but he somehow reinterpreted & restylized every ounce of it, and by some means found a way to harness his own desperation to fuel his efforts to deny the necessity of self-denial …namely the denial that anything good inherently dwells in him.

Thus Lance succeeded in his stratagem of subversion and unyielding self-regard, and thereby Lance suffocated his own soul and slipped into insanity.

Till We Have Faces Etc.

“Behold the I am handmaid of the Lord; be it unto me according to Thy Word.” [Lk. 1:38] = the key to dignity (the majesty that crowns us).

us:  “Thy Will be done.” = HEAVEN

God:  “thy will be done.” = HELL

*Don’t EVER look primarily at the church.  ALWAYS look at Jesus.  See Jesus.  Savor Jesus.  Look at the way Jesus is looking at the church.

Fredrick:  “Let’s walk through the vows [all 5 of’em].  Let’s look at John 3.  Let’s ‘get offended’ by John 6 and Matthew 16!

Janndryious:  “What do you want to do between dust and dust?

Charlie:  “Who is the person you trust the most?  …Would you entrust yourself as a baby in their care? …If you had to become an infant for a week – who would you entrust yourself to for care, nurture, provision, security, and support?  As a wee-little-baby, an incompetent infant, would you AGREE with all this person’s strategies of care? …Would you always feel ‘supported’ by them?

Londitius:  “What are these doing in here?  I thought we got rid of all of these?  Did you go purchase more?  I thought we said that we wouldn’t use these anymore.” [pessimism prophylactics]

Rick:  “Risky reputation questions???  …do these even exist to/for a dead dude?” [Gal. 2:20]

Folioicity:  “It starts with the relationship – the Father’s love!  It starts with childlike TRUST …a baby’s trust in his trustworthy Father – – – and then we launch into dying to self!

David:  “Death-Defying Dynasty.” [IDoK]

Moses:  “Jesus invites Tyler into HONESTY …which is to say that He invites Ty-Ty into SMALLNESS – WEAKNESS.  Jesus Himself became an EMBRYO! …and He ‘ended’ his earthly life on A CROSS!

Paul:  “ ‘Victim’ …admitting your small enough to be wronged …too weak to defend yourself and those you love.” […Heb. 4:15]  “Stuff happens and I feel it.  I cope via relying on myself – some scheme of man.  But GOD COMFORTS …not me.  Compassion and Conviction find their basis / their roots in God – not me.  I can only comfort the flock in proportion to – and from that honest place wherein – I have actually received true/real comfort from God Himself.  I comfort the flock by candidly sharing my experience of pain and distress, and God’s real/actual comfort.

Henri:  “THE WOUNDED HEALER.

Jo-Jo:  “Youz go away from folks in order to come back and be increasingly closer to folks.  Here is the dif. b/t isolation and solitude.  …the dif. b/t loving self, and loving God & loving others.

Mr. Continental:  “Success = Matthew 3:8.”

Mr. Fontatious:  “I ain’t earning nothing!  I ain’t entitled to nothing!

Ray:  “Your body is not your own! …1 Cor. 7.  YOU YIELD!

Denis:  “Anxious?  Guilty?  Bored? …groping for identity?

Steve:  “No rogue molecules tearing about the universe that somehow manage to operate independently of God’s providence. …Our expectations of what we think God should do in the world have their roots in a crucial foundational belief – – – A Genesis 3 lie of grandeur and big-ness.  …When our attempts to explain God’s actions are based solely on our observations, feelings, and expectations, we will almost certainly end up with a confused and inconsistent notion of God’s character and providence.  …HUMANS CRAVE EXPLANATION.  …decree; design; delegation. …God’s power is at work accomplishing His eternal purpose quite apart from our ability to see or make sense of what God is doing. …Bible Study – – – > Deut. 32.39; 1 Sam. 1.5-6; 2.6-10; Isa. 45.67; Psalm 139. …W/O God’s explicit disclosure, we have no way of identifying God’s particular and purposeful involvement at any historical moment. …We have to adjust our perspective from trying to figure out how our individual lives are being fulfilled to affirming that God is completing all that He has promised in Christ.  Christ and the Gospel are always to be at the center of our expectations and understanding of what God is doing in the world and in our lives. …GRATITUDE inclines me toward trust! – – – thereby enabling us to live in the midst of a world of relentless uncertainty bounded by a very solid certainty. …IS MY DESIRE TO EXPLAIN REALLY JUST MY DESIRE TO CTRL? – – – > To live gratefully – we live not with the clarity of the moment but with the certainty of the future!”

An Article by Steve Fröehlich

The long line of ants parading across the kitchen counter leads to a jar of sticky strawberry jelly left open last night by someone who raided the fridge for a midnight snack. A perturbed voice echoes through the house: “Who forgot to put the jelly away? Daa-ad?”

Blame. We point a finger at another person and say, “It’s your fault.” When we blame, we assign responsibility usually in an attempt to hold someone accountable (for not putting away the jelly) or to explain an event (a thousand ants doing the conga in the kitchen).
Blame is almost always an indictment. The prophet Nathan stood before King David to confront him about his adultery and the murder of Uriah. Perhaps you’ve imagined the scene as he solemnly utters the words, “Thou art the man.” Blame. Responsibility has been placed at the feet of David.

Or, as the sign on President Harry Truman’s White House desk announced, “The Buck Stops Here”. In a folksy way, Truman invited citizens to blame him if things in the country weren’t going the way they should. At the same time, he wanted to take the credit if things were going well.

Now, I know I’m being a bit cheeky in using the word “blame” since both credit and blame are the similar action of assigning responsibility. But the issue on my mind is how we assign responsibility to God for what goes on in the world and in our lives. My hunch is that when we “blame” God, the doctrine of God takes a beating, our relationship with God suffers, and we open ourselves to doubt and fear.

As I reflect on my own behavior, particularly the opinions I blurt out without thinking, I have to admit that I frequently, and sometimes carelessly, assign responsibility to God for what I observe and experience. I blame God for a lot of things, and I suspect you do, too. Why? We believe he is present and at work in our lives. Also, we want to understand why things happen, and we want to know who is responsible. If it’s God, we want to bless him; if Satan, we want to curse him. Right?

Expectations
Consider Martha as she grieves the death of her brother, Lazarus (John 11:17ff). The family has sent for Jesus to come, but Jesus, curiously, delays. He gets the urgent summons from his friends, but he waits. By the time he arrives in Bethany, Lazarus has been dead for four days. But, Martha confronts Jesus with a surprisingly bold greeting. “Lord if you had been here, my brother would not have died.”

Really.

Martha knows this… how? What is it that informs her expectation of what Jesus would have done had he arrived sooner? Well, to begin with she has a good theological head on her shoulders. Martha knows that Jesus is the Son of God: “I believe that you are the Christ, the Son of God, who is coming into the world.” Furthermore, she’s confident about God’s redemptive providence: “I know that my brother will rise again in the resurrection on the last day.” Plus, experience. She’s been friends with Jesus long enough to know that healing the sick is exactly the sort of thing Jesus did all the time.

Martha, a woman of noble faith, dares to nudge the savior to action with her belief that God will do anything he asks. But as there is a hint of disappointment in her remorse that Jesus did not come before Lazarus died, is there not in her prodding an air of expectation that what Jesus can do, he will do… or even must do?

Expectations that lead to blame
Our expectations of what we think God should do in the world have their roots in a crucial foundational belief: God is sovereign. He is the almighty, omnipotent God who causes “all things come to pass immutably, and infallibly” (Westminster Confession of Faith V.ii). As Job acknowledges, as he covers his mouth after surviving an unexplained gauntlet of suffering, “I know that you can do all things, and that no purpose of yours can be thwarted” (Job 42:2). God finishes what he starts both personally (Philippians 1:6) and creationally (Revelation 21:5). His providence is so comprehensive that not a hair falls from our heads or a sparrow to the ground apart from our Father’s care (Matthew 10:29; see also Heidelberg Catechism Lord’s Day 1). Or, to put it more whimsically, there are no rogue molecules tearing about the universe that somehow manage to operate independently of God’s providence.

The truth of God’s providence is the bedrock of hope, of what enables us to put our feet on the floor every morning with any measure of confidence. But we are not deists or fatalists. God’s sovereignty is not mechanistic indifference or impersonal determinism. We believe in the incarnation—God in Christ mingles his life with ours so that he is a “very present help” (Psalm 46:1), the good shepherd walking with us beside quiet streams and through death’s dark valleys (Psalm 23). Jesus promises, even at the moment of his ascension (what seems like a departure, even an abandonment), “I will never leave you or forsake you” (Matthew 28:20; cf. Joshua 1:15; Hebrews 13:5).

We believe not only in God’s presence, but also in prayer. We believe that God hears our praises and petitions, and he responds personally in real time. He delights in our adoration. He sees our needs and is moved. We believe God is at work in the world today, right now, in this place, even in our lives. Because of that Bible-informed belief, it’s no surprise that we attempt to explain what he is doing. Our efforts to make sense of God’s providence are so natural and genuine that it may seem silly to question them. In fact, questioning those responses may feel like we’re questioning God. “Do you doubt God is at work?”

But I’m not suggesting that we question God. I’m suggesting that we question ourselves.

Sometimes there are moments of crisp, blue-skyed clarity in which we know God has responded or acted. Hannah prayed for a son. God said, “yes” by opening her womb. Paul prayed for deliverance. God said “no” by leaving the thorn in his flesh.

When we believe that God has acted, we respond. On the one hand (when we like the outcome) we say things like, “God comforted and encouraged me. God healed me. God gave me a job. God brought me a husband or a wife. God protected me and provided for me. He has heard my cry.” But on the other hand (when we don’t like the outcome), we’re unsure what to say. What verb do we choose for God’s action when he seems silent, far away, or even adversarial?

When our attempts to explain God’s actions are based solely on our observations, feelings, and expectations, we will almost certainly end up with a confused and inconsistent notion of God’s character and providence. The ground beneath our feet suddenly becomes less solid.

Critics of Christianity, if we are honest, often see this inconsistency far more clearly than do we as Christians. If we credit God with healing our diseases and define his providence by his ability to provide convenient parking spaces at the mall, why do we not blame him for passenger jets being shot out of the sky and neighborhood dogs yapping their heads off at every passing car? It’s a fair question. Few Christians are willing to join the cynics in holding God responsible for tragedy and injustice or blaming God for bad things that happen. That is, except when we are self-assured that we are on the side of justice. Then, it seems that we are often quite willing to think of disease infecting the wicked or bombs and bullets tearing the flesh of our adversaries as the arm of God giving people what we think they deserve. As Bob Dylan sang more than half a century ago, “you don’t count the dead when God’s on your side.”

Blame
Many Christian athletes want to deflect the glory heaped upon them by the media and their fans by pointing their finger to God whenever they accomplish something great. A football player scores a touchdown and immediately points to heaven, kneels, or genuflects. I commend these athletes for their courage and witness. However, in all my many years of watching sports, I have never seen a Christian running back, sacked in the backfield by a 300-pound defender, reach around the massive body pinning him to the ground and point a finger to heaven, “All praise to you, Jesus, for this pain and humiliation.” Why not? Why are we willing to acknowledge that God is at work in a touchdown, but not in a sack?

Job understood something about our ability (or really, our lack of ability) to explain the specific actions of God that impact our lives. In his unresolved misery Job confesses what we somehow need to recapture in reshaping our attempts to explain God’s actions in the world and in our lives: “‘The Lord gave, and the Lord has taken away; blessed be the name of the Lord.’ In all this Job did not sin or charge God with wrong” (Job 1:21-22). He did not blame God.

Humans crave explanation. Urgency to understand drives research and discovery, and curiosity energizes wonder and creativity. Our bent to know why and how comes from our culture-making nature as God’s image bearers. Additionally, our belief in causality (things happen for at least mechanical if not teleological reasons) is an inescapable God-haunted dimension of our human existence. As Christians, we believe the ultimate explanation for “life, the universe, and everything” (thank you Douglas Adams) is the character and power of God.

However, if we’re going to try to make even basic sense of what God is doing, we need to begin by thinking more clearly about how God acts in the world. That is, how God exercises his providence in the everyday stuff of life (as well as the grand sweep of human history).

The big picture
We know that God’s power is at work in the world because of the two big events of human history central to Christian belief: creation and redemption. The world came into existence and Christ was raised from the dead by the power of God. Only God can do these things.

Decree: In Genesis 1, God expresses his sovereign, omnipotent power in three ways. When we think of omnipotence, it’s common for us to envision God’s zapping things into existence. When Jesus says to the blind man, “See,” what else can the man’s eyes do but what the creator has commanded them to do? When Jesus tells the winds and waves, “Be still,” the elements must obey him. This is the first expression of power we see in Genesis: Decree. Out of non-existence God causes existence. If we’re honest, most of us probably think this is the most God-like expression of power, and it’s how we prefer to see God do things. “God, just make it happen.”

Design: The second expression of God’s power appears when the creator directs the creatures of land, sea, and air to reproduce “according to their kind” (Genesis 1:24). In other words, God is commanding the creation to act according to the nature he has given to it. This is the second expression of power we see in Genesis: Design. God’s power is at work in the nature of the things he has made. When gravity pulls apples from the tree, when ice melts and wood burns, when dogs mate and have puppies, when hunger makes our tummies rumble, the power of God is at work in the nature of the world he has created.

Delegation: To his culture-making image bearers God gives royal responsibility to exercise stewardship and creativity over the whole world. Before God steps back and pronounces his “very good” blessing on his creation, he exercises the third expression of his power: Delegation. “Fill the earth,” commands the creator. Humans are given the near God-like ability and responsibility to oversee the ongoing work of creation. The power of God is at work in the choices his image bearers make on his behalf for the flourishing and completion of creation.

With this three-fold perspective of God’s expression of power, how might I expect to see God act when I pray, when I ask God to respond and use his power to heal me of the flu? Decree: I would be thrilled for God just zap my healing, to speak the word and eradicate the infection. There is precedent for God’s doing this and, therefore, good reason to hope that he might use his power in this way. Design: It may be that God will work in the nature of things—letting the flu run its course as my body regains strength perhaps encouraged by chicken soup, aspirin, or a physician’s skillful care. Delegation: It may be that God will work in my own choices that are integral to my recovery—rest, diet, exercise, learning about how better to care for my body.

However, what am I to conclude about God’s power, presence, and purpose when the answer to my prayers is shrouded in silence, when I can detect no evidence of intervention, change, or relief?

We can start by affirming that a mature faith will not privilege one expression of God’s power over another. Whether by decree, design, or delegation, God’s providence is at work. We also begin by acknowledging that God’s power is at work accomplishing his eternal purpose quite apart from our ability to see or make sense of what God is doing.

The Old Testament plays an extremely important role in informing us about God’s power at work in the world. (Yes, this is a shameless plug to keep reading the Old Testament) We see the activity of God in the lives of people and among the nations much more widely and specifically than in the New Testament. It’s critical to note that we would not have this information apart from God’s disclosure of it in his written revelation. But because he has disclosed it to us, we may be confident that it accurately depicts his power at work in the world, throughout history, and even today.

Consider these examples. The book of Job opens with an unprecedented glimpse behind the scenes—God’s power has the last word, but within the limits God has set, Satan is exposed as a prowling, “roaring lion, seeking someone to devour” (1 Peter 5:8). Through Isaiah God refers to Cyrus the pagan ruler of the Persians in messianic terms, as one integral to his redemptive purpose: “my shepherd” and “my anointed” (Isaiah 44:28-45:1). We are told that by the leprous pagan (at the time), Naaman, God gave victory to Syria over Israel (2 Kings 5:1). Jeremiah reveals that God wields Babylon as an arm of his judgment against his people, and yet still holds Babylon accountable for the wickedness of her actions (Jeremiah 25:8-14).

In his word, God pulls back the curtain just enough to let us know that he is actively involved in the world, in the affairs of nations, and in the unfolding of history. He is also actively involved in every aspect of our lives: life and death, wellbeing and calamity, prosperity and poverty, light and darkness (Deuteronomy 32:39; 1 Samuel 1:5-6; 2:6-10; Isaiah 45:67). Wherever he is present (Psalm 139), he is at work.

The knowledge that God is everywhere at work resides at the heart of the life of faith. This belief is crucially foundational for our life in the world as followers of Christ. However, what we lack (and will never have) is a comprehensive interpretive key that connects our observation and experience of events in this life with a corresponding explanation of what God is doing in all that we observe and experience. Without God’s explicit disclosure, we have no way of identifying God’s particular and purposeful involvement at any historical moment. Inspired by God’s Spirit, the prophets interpret events in the life of God’s people (draught, harvest, victory, defeat) to make the explicit connections between history and the hand of God, connections that are beyond our ability to make.

Back to the present
Long after the voices of the prophets have fallen silent, we may continue to say with confidence, God is at work in the world and in our lives today. God answers prayer. God is omnipotently accomplishing his eternal purpose in creation and redemption. How then do we talk about God’s actions in the world right now as we experience it? On what basis do we say, “God did that”? Or, should we ever say, “God did that”? One young woman prays from genuine faith in Christ for a hoped-for relationship that flourishes and fulfills. Similarly a young man prays for a hoped-for relationship that ends in disappointment and rejection. On what basis can or should either of these two Christians say, “God fulfilled my relationship” or “God frustrated my relationship”?

It’s hard to look past our present circumstances to recognize that God is never doing only one thing at any given time or place. God’s power is at work all around us in a complex array of expressions. He is working by the nature and design of the world, and he is working in our choices and actions as we carry out the responsibilities delegated to us. He is working by decree. In any one circumstance God can be working out justice, provision, and discipline in ways that to our limited perspective may seem contradictory. He can at the same time be restraining evil, using evil, and advancing the kingdom. In short, God is at work in multi-faceted ways that we can never fully comprehend.

It’s difficult to admit that God’s providence is not all about me. We must not forget that while God always acts personally toward his image bearers, the focus of his action is on the redemption of his people and the world he has made for them. We have to adjust our perspective from trying to figure out how our individual lives are being fulfilled to affirming that God is completing all that he has promised in Christ. Christ and the gospel are always to be at the center of our expectations and understanding of what God is doing in the world and in our lives. Or, to put it another way, our trust in God’s provision of our daily bread needs to be tethered to our longing for his kingdom to come and for his will to be done on earth as it is in heaven.

Refining our perspective
How does this shift in thinking translate into everyday practice? Does this change in perspective really make a difference in how we live by faith and worship God? I believe it can, although the change will likely be gradual as we learn new patterns of thought and speech.

We all live with expectations. Many of us live with unmet expectations that hold us hostage, sometimes even in a death grip. Many of us live with deep disappointment and anger toward God for what we think he has or hasn’t done. Many of us live with fear because we don’t know what God will do. Many of us pursue careers and relationships with the expectations of specific outcomes that we connect (often inaccurately) to God’s promises and providence: marriage, bonuses, loyalty, success.

Those who are pressed to hope in God amid all the chaos, injustice, death, and evil of life, look eagerly for reassurance that God is present and at work in the thick of our woundedness, despair, powerlessness, and brokenness. We read and believe the promise of God’s presence and faithfulness, but we also want to see with our eyes that he is with us and at work. It’s the expectation that we should be able to see with our eyes (hoping to use God’s secret decoder ring) that gets us into trouble.

Yet seeing the indisputable hand of God at work does not automatically give us the courage and confidence we want. Moses met God at the burning bush but was still fearful and reluctant. After witnessing the plagues of Egypt and meeting with God face to face, he still pleaded for confirmation from God (Psalm 90). Moses, like us, had to stand with confidence on the character of God, not on the satisfaction that his experiences and observations met his expectations.

I wonder if this hopeful expectation is behind much of the appeal of the prosperity gospel movement. Christians want reassurance that prayer works. Christians want vindication for their causes and validation that they’ve heard God’s voice in their decision-making. So, the proof of God’s presence and blessing is good health and a new car. The proof that we really are in sync with the Spirit is all the money we raised to build a new church building. Or the formula works in reverse, too. What more evidence do we need that God has cursed the United States than the legalization of abortion and same-sex marriage?

As students of history, surely we can say that God is at work when justice triumphs over evil, can’t we? Hitler was defeated and his barbaric cruelty was brought to an end. Surely this was the hand of God at work in history, and we can say, “God did that,” can’t we? However, when we leave the comfortable distance of generalities, how do we assign responsibility for the individual actions that brought about that victory? Was God behind dropping the bomb on Hiroshima? Was God involved in brokering the Yalta Conference that doomed thousands to the Gulag? Of the many events that comprise the accomplishment of V-Day and the defeat of Hitler, which ones are we willing to say, “God did that”?

On a more everyday scale you might recall being stranded on the road with a flat tire. A stranger stopped to help, and you said to your benefactor, “God sent you.” You might recall heading for a safe place in the house when the tornado sirens wailed. Afterwards, you said, “God directed the storm away from us” (which means by implication that he directed the storm to wreak havoc upon someone who uttered the same prayer you prayed). You remember being in a car accident in which everyone else was injured in some way, and you said, “God protected me from harm” (which means that he either failed to protect the others or inflicted injury upon them). You cannot forget how lonely you felt, completely alone, until that young man spoke to you at the church picnic. You said with confidence, “I’m not lonely any more—I’m loved. God has sent him into my life.” Many of you will never forget the struggle to choose a college or a major, and after much prayer and conversation you said, “God opened the door for me to go to UCLA and major in music.” Many of you have asserted with confidence that God told you whom to marry.

But, is this the most helpful and accurate way to speak about God’s work in our lives and in the world? Is it necessary that we be able to say that we clearly and unequivocally understand what God is doing at this moment in our lives? Do we have to explain God? Do we have to justify his actions to our satisfaction before we are willing to trust him or invite others to trust him?

I want to suggest that too often when we are explaining (“God did that”), we are blaming. I believe there is a better way to affirm and respond to God’s presence and work.

Consider this alternative proposition: Gratitude is better than explanation. If this proposition is true, then we have some learning to do. But first, two comments.

1. We have to say something.
Please note that I am not saying that explanation is automatically wrong or arrogant. In the Bible God does a lot of explaining and calls us to be ready to give an explanation of the gospel (1 Peter 3:15). But when it comes to expressing our view of God’s action in our lives and in the world, I’m suggesting that the language and posture of gratitude is better. It seems to me that the perspective of gratitude inclines us toward trust, thereby enabling us to live in the midst of a world of relentless uncertainty bounded by a very solid certainty.

I believe whole-heartedly that most of us use the language of explanation in an attempt to honor God. We believe in him and his promises, and we want to affirm that he is present and at work. We want to give him glory for the grace and faithfulness that he has lavished upon us.

But this shift from explanation to gratitude could easily be frustrating, and I don’t want to discourage you from acknowledging God’s grace at work in your life. Keep confessing him in the most honest and articulate way you know. But at the same time, don’t stop thinking about how you express that confession. Perhaps some of the ideas that follow will help you.

2. God is at work in ways we will never fully understand.
It bears repeating that even when we are confident that God is responsible for specific events in our lives or in the world, we must remember that he is at work (even in those same events) in more ways than we can comprehend. In every event, in varying degrees, he is attending to the completion of the redemption of each of his children. He is attending to the work of the church and the missio dei. He is attending to the preservation of the world and the completion of creation. He is restraining Satan and evil. He is punishing the wicked and executing justice. He is answering prayer. He is keeping his promises. He is lavishing grace indiscriminately upon people everywhere. He is making Christ known. He is delighting in all he has made. He is moving history toward the consummation.

All these speak to the complexities of God’s actions in the world. But there is also the dark mystery of a “frowning providence,” the giving and taking of which Job spoke. God does not always send the gentle rain—sometimes he sends the flood. He sends disease as well as healing. He closes as well as opens the womb, gives brevity of life as well as length of days. He impoverishes as well as prospers, makes war as well as peace, hardens hearts as well as opens ears. We know this because God tells us in his Word.

So, even if we could accurately explain an event and say, “God did that,” we are inescapably ignorant of all the other things God is doing in that same event. There is always more to what God is doing than we can ever know because it requires an understanding that belongs to God alone. Parents experience a similar limitation in their children. When a child believes the end of the world has come when a girl turns down his prom invitation, parents know there is so much more at work in their young man’s life than just the pain of rejection. We often try to explain away the pain by saying “this will all look very different 5 years from now.” But your young man wants an explanation for THIS moment. As compassionate parents, would we not give anything to call all the king’s horses and all the king’s men to put Humpty Dumpty together again… right now, because behind the explanation is a desire to heal the wound and fix what is broken. Somewhere, somehow, I believe our desire to explain is connected with a desire to control, a desire to fix and manage things, an impulse that reminds us that the line between compassion and idolatry can be razor thin.

Similarly with God, an explanation for one event does not begin to explain all that God is doing right now. We see little, but often too quickly or glibly presume to know much, and our determination to find explanations often betrays an insistence that circumstances be different. Therefore, incomplete explanations (which are all we are able to muster) too frequently lead to distortions, misunderstanding, and manipulation.
Instead of presuming that we have God figured out, let’s give thanks.
Over 50 times in the Psalms we are summoned to give thanks. A favorite refrain of the poets saturating their praise is “Give thanks to the Lord for he is good; his steadfast love endures forever!”

The theme of thanksgiving and gratitude continues through the New Testament. Consider these 2 examples:

Whatever you do, in word or deed, do everything in the name of the Lord Jesus, giving thanks to God the Father through him (Colossians 3:17).

Rejoice always, pray without ceasing, give thanks in all circumstances. This is the will of God in Christ Jesus for you (1 Thessalonians 6:16-18).

Our response to every circumstance of life is to be joyful and prayerful thanksgiving. However, let’s not fool ourselves. That’s a tall order because many of life’s situations do not naturally or easily evoke joy and gratitude. But the focus of our response must be on the person and character of God, on knowing him well rather than having life figured out.

In what ways, then, does gratitude liberate us from the bondage and burden of explanation?

1. We are free to be grateful because we know how the story ends.
While happiness breezes through our lives as the fickle and fleeting fair weather companion of pleasant moments, gratitude (like joy) is grounded in the certainty of what endures. Martha says to Jesus, “I know that my brother will rise again in the resurrection on the last day.” It would be difficult to exaggerate the practical importance of her affirmation. We know how the story ends. Even if we cannot explain how all the parts and pieces of what we experience today fit together as a seamless whole, we know how the story ends. Regardless of whether Jesus raises Lazarus from the dead or not, he will rise again, and nothing is lost.

The Apostle John stands slack-jawed at the apocalyptic vision unfolding before him. He sees the ancient promises of God coming together in fulfillment. Creation is flourishing as God intended. The nations have gathered like the stars of heaven in the glory of God’s presence, and shalom covers the earth. Evil has been vanquished and sin, banished.
Christ, the Lamb, is on his throne, the host of the great feast. And, all creation sings. The incomprehensible wonder of the sight immobilizes John until the One seated on the throne nudges him: See with your own eyes. “Behold, I am making all things new. Write this down, for these words are trustworthy and true” (Revelation 21:5). Take in the sight of this wonderful vision, and record in your book what you have seen so that generations yet to come might have confidence and hope.

This is God’s gift to us through John, uniting what’s happening in our lives today with the providential completion of Creation. This trustworthy and true testimony becomes the solid ground upon which we “live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28). We are living today (even amid tremendous chaos and confusion) toward certainty. The certainty of life is NOT dependent upon our ability to interpret the events of life. The uncertainty of life accompanies our incapacity to grasp how God is able to be at work using all the stuff of life to accomplish his purpose. By contrast, the great certainty for us each day in every circumstance of life is that God is at work taking us closer and closer to the end for which he has ordained Creation and Redemption.

Perhaps the often quoted “all things work together for good” of Romans 8:28 comes to mind. Too often we have been burdened with tortured readings of Paul’s assurance. Sometimes we are told to believe that bad things are really good things in disguise. Sometimes we are told, when bad things happen, not to fret because God has something better in store for us—a better job, a better spouse, a better outcome. We are told that cancer, the loss of a job, the death of a child, are all means by which God makes something “good.” Life may have given us lemons, you may have heard, but God makes lemonade.

But these well-meaning consolations are not the assurance Paul offers. The “good” which God is working in all things is our salvation, his calling to himself, the fulfillment of his purpose, the certainty of a journey that ends in glory. Believing that God is at work in all things does not mean that death, disease, and loneliness are transformed into anything other than what they are, evidence of the brokenness of a fallen world. As Jesus did not exempt himself from his full participation in the trouble of the world as we know it, even death, so he calls us to live in this world as it is. This is why the voice and vision of the artist is crucial to mature faith.

The promise and assurance of Paul is not that we will be able to explain how God is making good out of brokenness and evil right now. The confident hope is that God really is at work in all things to complete what he started, to finish the salvation that has been won in Christ, and to bring to completion the world that he created. No explanation is given to Job as he sits in his ash heap scraping the scabs and pus from his body, but (anticipating Paul) he affirms this hope: “in my flesh I shall see God” (Job 19:26). No “good” is in sight as he staggers beneath the loss of everything but his life. Yet he concludes: “I know that you can do all things, and that no purpose of yours can be thwarted” (Job 42:2). Job situates his suffering and confusion within the certainty of God’s character and covenant. He knows how the story ends.

To live gratefully we live not with the clarity of the moment but with the certainty of the future. Lest anyone accuse us of simply living in denial, we point to the cross. The cross has become our rock, our confidence, and the reason we dare to live with certainty, even in the face of failure, injustice, and the gut-wrenching sorrows of life. My health, my job, my success are not unimportant, but the Cross gives us freedom to face life and death, sickness and health, wealth and poverty, and say, “Thank you”—but, “thank you” for what? We definitely do not give thanks for the evil and broken things themselves. Rather we say “thank you” to the One who holds all these things in his omnipotent hand.

There is no uncertainty for us as Christians about how things end. Our health does not speed the success of God’s purpose and our failures do not impede it. The Cross is the great demonstration in history that God keeps his promises so that in every situation of life we may say truthfully and joyfully, “Thank you, Father, for all that you are accomplishing even in this death that confuses me and this disappointment that is breaking my heart.” It is to the certainty of the cross that we come each week in the celebration of the Eucharist, the first fruits of the world made new, and the oath of God’s covenant ratified by the resurrection.

2. We are free to be grateful because every circumstance of life is an occasion to declare the character and kingdom of God.
If worship resides at the heart of the Christian life, then all of life is a confession of who God is. All of life is our praise and adoration for his presence, his virtues, his wisdom; and all of life is ordered by the shalom of his kingdom. Amid her grief, Martha offers her confession of who Jesus is, “You are the Christ, the Son of God.” Martha’s worship prompts us to ask if we could make this confession in our grief.

Every circumstance of life and death, sickness and health, wealth and poverty is an occasion to say with gratitude, “Jesus is a great Savior.” Paul reflected on his wide range of experiences as a church planter and apostle in this way: “I have learned in whatever situation I am to be content [Surely contentment and gratitude go hand in hand]. I know how to be brought low, and I know how to abound. In any and every circumstance, I have learned the secret of facing plenty and hunger, abundance and need. I can do all [of these] things through him who strengthens me” (Philippians 4:11-13). Paul learned to view all his life situations through the lens both of Jesus’s character and presence as well as the reality of the kingdom of God. Gratitude. In every circumstance the character of Jesus is being revealed and the shalom of God’s kingdom is breaking through.

Everything entrusted to us—life, experiences, relationships, abilities, possessions, ideas—is a summons to stewardship. Many of these things we readily recognize as gifts, as good things that we are glad to receive. But not all of them. We are stewards of weakness, sickness, poverty, and loneliness as well. Yet in God’s economy, all of these things are entrusted to us for glory—Christ’s glory made visible in us, and Christ’s glory bestowed on others. This pattern has been the way of God’s people from the beginning when Yahweh spoke to Abraham, “In you all the families of the earth shall be blessed” (Genesis 12:3) and to Jacob, “Your offspring shall be like the dust of the earth, and you shall spread abroad to the west and to the east and to the north and to the south, and in you and your offspring shall all the families of the earth be blessed” (Genesis 28:14). Those who have received God’s grace are to make visible and present God’s grace to others in the character and kingdom of our Lord. Our greatest joy in life is to exalt our God—Father, Son, and Spirit. Or, in other words, having received grace from God, all of life is to be worship to God. Our calling as his people is to love the Lord our God with our whole beings and to love our neighbors as ourselves (Deuteronomy 6:5; Leviticus 19:18; Matthew 22:37). Our worship to God rises from the very dust of the ground and the air we breathe so that in every circumstance our lives are directed simultaneously in love toward God (supremely) and others (necessarily).

As a result, Paul says that we are to comfort others with the comfort with which we have been comforted (2 Corinthians 1:4). We are to be kind toward others and forgiving, as God has been kind and tenderhearted to us (Ephesians 4:31). Grace does not arrive in our lives like mail, like a train that has reached the station. Grace does indeed come to us as the gift of healing, peace, confidence, and strength. But, as Peter says, we are to be stewards of grace: “As each has received a gift, use it to serve one another as good stewards of God’s varied and abundant grace” (1 Peter 4:10). The fruitful expressions of Christ’s character by the indwelling of the Spirit are to result in others being enriched by God’s grace for his glory (Galatians 5:22-26). Gratitude produces the fragrance of the world made new, the aroma of shalom in the kingdom of God.

It’s easy to be glib about living all of life for God’s glory. It’s easy to hide behind theologically nuanced masks and deny our own desperate need for grace. But there is no glory in triumphalism, the determination to be impervious to hardship and suffering—there is no worship offered in rugged self-reliance, only the prideful trumpeting of self-sufficiency and independence.

Shifting the trajectory of our lives often takes time, especially when we are learning to respond to deep sorrow and great injustice. It takes others coming alongside to comfort us with the comfort with which they have been comforted before we can see our own circumstances through the hopeful lens of the gospel. When God’s grace washes over us as we complete the sufferings of Christ (2 Corinthians 1:5; Philippians 3:10; Colossians 1:24), we are humbled in wonder and worship. We put our hands to our lips; we silence any effort to explain or blame; and we live by faith in our resurrected Lord who is at work now—he is making all things new.

I’ll stand before the Lord of Song
With nothing on my tongue but Hallelujah

[Leonard Cohen]

Copyright © 2015 Steve Froehlich 

March 13th, 2015

Margie:  Plans are like egg whites, they can slip through your fingers and onto the floor so easily and unexpectedly.  And there’s no getting them back into the bowl when that happens.  AND – – – > here’s a BIG question:  “How can I love people more purely without attempting to manipulate them into becoming what I want them to be?  How can I love anything without making myself the central reference point and the motivation for acts of generosity?”

I like to live pretending that I don’t think I’m the center of the universe.

I must love weights and cumbersome worries – – – because I go “bargain shopping” for them …it’s like I can’t get enough of them!  There in every room of my house!  They are my prize posessions it seems!

What are you laying aside?  What are you picking up?  What course are you on?  What path, and at what pace?  What keep you on that path?  What keeps you at that pace?  What are you enduring?  Why?  What are you despising?  Why?  Where and when will you sit down?  Who’s sovereign?  Where’s the command center?  Who’s giving the orders?  Who’s fueling/financing the project?  Who’s in charge of finishing this thing?  What’s in view?  What’s the foremost thing?  What’s being offered?  Who’s pleased with the project?  Who’s pleased with what’s being offered?  What is the most pure, true, and proper thing?  What is making your groan?  …Is it “groan-worthy”?  …Are you becoming a more compassionate and less egotistical person?

Donald:  How “wonderfully human”!

Steve:  this world is broken & alienated.

Bonnie:  I shall provide honest and practical feedback if you like.  Y’all listen-up.

Henry:  May I humbly endeavor to keep us all on task?  …also, don’t disregard the deetz.

Paul:  I ain’t going to golf my life away!

Anita:  I help!

Exists. Infinitely Wise. Loves me.

And here’s a bonus bit of info – – – > “God isn’t looking for winners …He’s looking for disciples.  …God is far more interested in covenant obedience than vocational achievement.a tragic life isn’t tragic if it’s lived in fidelity to what Christ asks of us in the circumstances he gives us.” – Dale Ralph Davis

WKTM’BP

Sailing?

Rowing?

Drifting?

Sinking?

…KnM that ALL are in the VAST wilderness of the sea!

A – – – > I

P – – – > I

Relationship

Reputation

Reign & Rule

Rations

Remissions

Rudder (guide) & Refuge (hide)

Laugh & Lament

Invisible [Col. 1:15; 1 Tim. 1:17; Heb. 11:27; Jn. 20:29]

Twas Tempted [Heb. 4:15]

Afoot [Jn. 3:8; Rom. 8:28]

HONEY.  HONEY.  HONEY. …Psalm 34:8

Prayer = being brutally honest in the presence of God.

…not getting stuff from God, but getting mehr of God Himself (Lam. 3:24; Isa. 64:7)

Not magical.  Not mechanical.

Prayer is ONLY for the desperate.

Prayer is the practice of Spiritual Strength & Sensitivity.

HONEY.  HONEY.  HONEY. …Psalm 34:8

*Feeling sorry for yourself is NOT the same thing as hating your sin.

Witch Huntz

…one man said to me, “three hundred years ago people in England were putting witches to death. Was that what you call the Rule of Human Nature or Right Conduct?” But surely the reason we do not execute witches is that we do not believe there are such things. If we did–if we really thought that there were people going about who had sold themselves to the devil and received supernatural powers from him in return and were using these powers to kill their neighbours or drive them mad or bring bad weather–surely we would all agree that if anyone deserved the death penalty, then these filthy quislings did? (C.S. Lewis, Mere Christianity, Chapter 2, p.14)

Smoke’n The Pipe Some Mehr

You can’t perform the office of elder worthily unless you see the worthiness of the office (…and the worthiness of the office is a reality only insofar as the King of kings, and Good Shepherd, has ordained/established the office – and thereby inescapably endowed it with worthiness).

You can’t follow Christ as He is worthy to be followed unless you KNOW & SAVOR His worthiness.

…We must teach not only what is, but the VALUE of what is.

March 9th, 2015

Bo:  Do you own any scuba gear?

Gina:  No. …Why?

Bo:  I’m thinking about diving down to the deeper parts of the berg later today.

Gina:  When did that craving come about?

Bo:  Last week – when I realized that Fernando is a soul.  …something that Clive said caused me to sober up to the realities of souls.

Gina:  You know that things could become somewhat tense, confusing, problematic, dramatic, awkward, dark, dismal, murky, and what not if you actually choose to dive down there?

Bo:  We all WANT something Gina …I mean we’re all desperate for something …the evidence of desperation is abundant …there’s something(s) we gotta have or else we’ll die! …Think about it, what do you really really want?  …or, when was a time when you were obviously disappointed or frustrated? – trace that feeling back to the question, “What was it that I NEEDED, but I DIDN’T GET IT?

Gina:  I don’t know.

Bo:  It probably had something to do with INTIMACY or IMPACT.  …A relational need, or a work endeavor (…and in my experience, control is tantamount in both! – – – > in other words, disappointment is always hand-in-hand with the reality of our inescapable limitations/lack of control).  Have you ever felt like “the victim.”

Gina:  YES.

Bo:  Tell me more…

Gina:  Where is all of this coming from Bo?  Where are you?  Clearly you’re passionate about all this …WHAT’S YOUR DEAL?  Do you feel like you have to hide?  What are you desperate to cover up?  What are you afraid of?  What are you ashamed of?  WHAT HAPPENED?

Bo:  Where are you Gina?  What did you need, but you didn’t get it? …What if you don’t get it? …What if you never get it?  …What if you do get it??? (then what?).  How do you feel about autonomy/ctrl?  Chaos?  Confusion? (not knowing?).  Saying “IDK.”  Stability?  Satisfaction?

[All of sudden Jason L. Riley bursts into the room]

Jason:  Please stop “helping” us!  We gotta BE HONEST!  We’re messed up!  We’re all attempting to blame-shift and deflect …incessantly avoiding our shame.  Racism has become “The Victim Card”/”Get Out of Jail Free!” – – – the all purpose “explanation” for bad black outcomes, be they social or economic.  If you disagree and are white, you’re a bigot.  If you disagree and are black you’re a sell-out. …The Left wants to blame these outcomes on racial animus and poverty, but back in the 1940’s and ’50’s, when racial discrimination was legal and black poverty was much higher than today, the black crime rate was lower.  …The Left wants to blame these outcomes on “the system,” but blacks have long been part of running that system.  …The Left, wracked by guilt over America’s diabolical treatment of blacks, decided to hold them to different standards of behavior.  Blacks, Siege writes, were invited to “enter the larger society” on their own terms.  …Libreals relentlessly attempt to “improve conditions for blacks” without “passing judgment” on antisocial black culture.  DECONSTRUCTION and RECONSTRUCTION needs to happen amidst ghetto attitudes towards schools, work, marriage, and child-rearing.  The black culture has to do this – they have to decide to do it – they have to want to do it (Repentance is indispensable… FOR ALL HUMANITY!  Repent and be baptized – that is the wisdom of God!).

Marcus:  I know that time has numbered my days …And I’ll go along with everything you say …But I’ll ride home laughing, look at me now …The walls of my town, they come crumbling down …And my ears hear the call of my unborn sons …And I know their choices color all I’ve done …But I’ll explain it all to the watchman’s son, …I ain’t ever lived a year better spent in love …’Cause I’ll know my weakness, know my voice …And I’ll believe in grace and choice …And I know perhaps my heart is farce, …But I’ll be born without a mask …Like the city that nurtured my greed and my pride, …I stretched my arms into the sky …I cry Babel! Babel! Look at me now …Then the walls of my town, they come crumbling down …You ask where will we stand in the winds that will howl, …As all we see will slip into the cloud …So come down from your mountain and stand where we’ve been, …You know our breath is weak and our body thin …Press my nose up, to the glass around your heart …I should’ve known I was weaker from the start, …You’ll build your walls and I will play my bloody part …To tear, tear them down, …Well I’m gonna tear, tear them down …Cause I know my weakness, know my voice …And I’ll believe in grace and choice …And I know perhaps my heart is farce, …But I’ll be born without a mask.

Joe-Joe:  Hey dudes!  I couldn’t help but overhear y’all talking about a variety of things. I just wanna say, “EMPHASIS.” 

Gina:  What are you talking about Joe-Joe?

Joe-Joe:  Emphasis/Centrality is on Examination.  Read all about it in 1 Cor. 10; or the entire Gospel of Matthew, or Mark, or Luke, or John!  Read about it in Romans 7, or 1 Timothy!  If you assume you STAND (i.e. if you assume that your regenerate just because you’re “sons of Abraham,” or “circumcised,” or “baptized,” or “born to Christian parents,” or “a member of a church,” or because you “partake of the Lord’s Supper,” or because you “read the Bible,” etc. then take heed (i.e. examine yourself – invest time in SERIOUS REFLECTION) – and Examine yourselves, to see whether you are in the faith. Test yourselves. Or do you not realize this about yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you?—unless indeed you fail to meet the test! (2 Corinthians 13:5) – – – >

Matthew 3:10

Even now the axe is laid to the root of the trees. Every tree therefore that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.


Matthew 7:15

A Tree and Its Fruit

“Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves.


Matthew 7:17

So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit.


Matthew 7:18

A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit.


Matthew 7:19

Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.


Matthew 12:33

A Tree Is Known by Its Fruit

“Either make the tree good and its fruit good, or make the tree bad and its fruit bad, for the tree is known by its fruit.


Matthew 21:19

And seeing a fig tree by the wayside, he went to it and found nothing on it but only leaves. And he said to it, “May no fruit ever come from you again!” And the fig tree withered at once.

Bo: I think it’s good to presume.

Joe-Joe:  Show me in the Bible where you get that impression …actually PROVE TO ME THAT YOUR UNDERSTANDING/VIEW/INTERPRETATION IS THE BIBLICAL EMPHASIS!  …On matters that so clearly talk about judgment, and things that clearly have SO MUCH to do with the PERSON signified (i.e. Jesus Christ) – we really need to see an abundance of FRUIT/EVIDENCE & EMPHASIS!

Gina:  I want to say – – – > “Faithful IMAGINATION” & Mature Humble Balancedness.

Tyler:  I dig what Joe-Joe is saying:

I don’t want to get sucked into the vortex of this debate, but I shall put my cards on the table…

My BIG Question is So What?  What’s the primary EMPHASIS of Scripture?  What’s the primary APPLICATION of the Word of God?

…How do the elders of the church most emphatically and definitively love God and love others?
 

No matter what views are classified as “in bounds” or not – the overwhelming EMPHASIS of Scripture is on an individual’s heart and soul (Ps. 51:17) …being born again (i.e. conversion from death to life …becoming, and being, a new creation (2 Cor. 5:17; Gal. 6:15).

But a Jew is one inwardly, and circumcision is a matter of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the letter. His praise is not from man but from God (Rom. 2:29)

Circumcise therefore the foreskin of your heart, and be no longer stubborn.
(Deuteronomy 10:16)

And the LORD your God will circumcise your heart and the heart of your offspring, so that you will love the LORD your God with all your heart and with all your soul, that you may live. (Deuteronomy 30:6)

Circumcise yourselves to the LORD; remove the foreskin of your hearts, O men of Judah and inhabitants of Jerusalem; lest my wrath go forth like fire, and burn with none to quench it, because of the evil of your deeds.” (Jeremiah 4:4)  …I get the impression that Jeremiah was saying this to BOTH the individual 8-day-old who was circumcised, and the individual 80-year-old who was circumcised.  …i.e. circumcision of the heart doesn’t seem to be assumed (see also 1 Cor. 10:12; 2 Cor. 13:5).

Jesus EMPHASIZES self-examination – and not assuming that “you’re a Christian” just because He placed you in a covenant family:
So Jesus said to the Jews who had believed him, “If you abide in my word, you are truly my disciples, and you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.” They answered him, “We are offspring of Abraham and have never been enslaved to anyone. How is it that you say, ‘You will become free’?” Jesus answered them, “Truly, truly, I say to you, everyone who practices sin is a slave to sin. The slave does not remain in the house forever; the son remains forever. So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed. I know that you are offspring of Abraham; yet you seek to kill me because my word finds no place in you. I speak of what I have seen with my Father, and you do what you have heard from your father.”  They answered him, “Abraham is our father.” Jesus said to them, “If you were Abraham’s children, you would be doing the works Abraham did, but now you seek to kill me, a man who has told you the truth that I heard from God. This is not what Abraham did. You are doing the works your father did.” They said to him, “We were not born of sexual immorality. We have one Father—even God.” Jesus said to them, “If God were your Father, you would love me, for I came from God and I am here. I came not of my own accord, but he sent me. Why do you not understand what I say? It is because you cannot bear to hear my word. You are of your father the devil, and your will is to do your father’s desires. He was a murderer from the beginning, and does not stand in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he lies, he speaks out of his own character, for he is a liar and the father of lies. But because I tell the truth, you do not believe me. Which one of you convicts me of sin? If I tell the truth, why do you not believe me? Whoever is of God hears the words of God. The reason why you do not hear them is that you are not of God.” (John 8:31-47)

Throughout the Gospels Jesus doesn’t let people assume anything …He’s always forcing people to think, examine, and ponder their position in relationship to Jesus Christ …not primarily the church – but Jesus Himself (i.e. the Person signified in the sacraments!).  Forcing people to examine themselves – this is one of the primary reasons He taught in parables. …Jesus is always answering questions with questions (provoking people to evaluate where they stand, what’s in their heart, and the status of their soul). …He emphasizes the necessity of every single individual on the planet having a healthy identity crisis (e.g. Jn. 3:1-8 is normative, and if we are to presume anything – we presume that everyone – covenant children included – are being invited by Jesus into the remarkably unpleasant process which Nicodemus is being exposed to in John chapter 3 – – – the upending of our presumptions, and the collapse of our assumptions […this is the liberating, new-creation, unpleasant-ness Paul speaks of in places like Gal. 2 and Philippians 3]).


The application (throughout Scripture) is on self-examination, self-reflection, and bearing fruit in keeping with repentance (growing in grace):

Therefore let anyone who thinks that he stands take heed lest he fall (1 Cor. 10:12)

…this comes immediately after talking about a bunch of people who were covenant children – who presumed they were “saved.”

Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. (1 Corinthians 11:28)

Examine yourselves, to see whether you are in the faith. Test yourselves. Or do you not realize this about yourselves, that Jesus Christ is in you?—unless indeed you fail to meet the test! (2 Cor. 13:5)

Matthew 3:10

Even now the axe is laid to the root of the trees. Every tree therefore that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.


Matthew 7:15

“Beware of false prophets, who come to you in sheep’s clothing but inwardly are ravenous wolves.


Matthew 7:17

So, every healthy tree bears good fruit, but the diseased tree bears bad fruit.


Matthew 7:18

A healthy tree cannot bear bad fruit, nor can a diseased tree bear good fruit.


Matthew 7:19

Every tree that does not bear good fruit is cut down and thrown into the fire.


Matthew 12:33

“Either make the tree good and its fruit good, or make the tree bad and its fruit bad, for the tree is known by its fruit.


Matthew 21:19

And seeing a fig tree by the wayside, he went to it and found nothing on it but only leaves. And he said to it, “May no fruit ever come from you again!” And the fig tree withered at once.


For I do not understand my own actions. For I do not do what I want, but I do the very thing I hate. Now if I do what I do not want, I agree with the law, that it is good. So now it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me. For I know that nothing good dwells in me, that is, in my flesh. For I have the desire to do what is right, but not the ability to carry it out. For I do not do the good I want, but the evil I do not want is what I keep on doing. Now if I do what I do not want, it is no longer I who do it, but sin that dwells within me. So I find it to be a law that when I want to do right, evil lies close at hand. For I delight in the law of God, in my inner being, but I see in my members another law waging war against the law of my mind and making me captive to the law of sin that dwells in my members. Wretched man that I am! Who will deliver me from this body of death? Thanks be to God through Jesus Christ our Lord! So then, I myself serve the law of God with my mind, but with my flesh I serve the law of sin. (Romans 7:15-25)
Therefore, since we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, let us also lay aside every weight, and sin which clings so closely, and let us run with endurance the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus, the founder and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising the shame, and is seated at the right hand of the throne of God. (Hebrews 12:1-2)

These two verses are extraordinarily clarifying – – – because immediately after talking about THE TRUE/INVISIBLE CHURCH – people who actually lived by faith …and after explicitly being reminded that we (Christians) are surrounded by this covenant family of faith – the EMPHASIS is NOT on recognizing our membership in that family – but rather the PRIMARY EMPHASIS is on fixing our eyes on Jesus – a Savior of those who sincerely see their wretchedness (see Rom. 7; 1 Tim. 1:15) – a Savior who insisted on being CRUCIFIED!
…We have to be told to fix our attention on Christ crucified – we cannot presume that our focus will naturally gravitate toward a gruesomely crucified King (i.e the thing signified in the Lord’s Supper).  Not to mention – the entirety of chapter 11 emphasizes what it actually means to live by faith – which takes constant examination and consideration (see Heb. 11:26) as opposed to assuming that “I am a Christian because I’ve been circumcised [or baptized]” …that is one of the worst/most dangerous things a person can do (see 1 Cor. 10:1-6; and Rom. 9:6-7; 1 Cor. 11:29).


For I decided to know nothing among you except Jesus Christ and him crucified.
(1 Corinthians 2:2)

Paul doesn’t presume to know, nor does he presume that the church in Corinth remembers that Christ insisted on being crucified.  In the Lord’s Supper – the EMPHASIS is on remembering (i.e. examining ourselves individually regarding) the thing signified (i.e. Christ crucified) – – – Whoever, therefore, eats the bread or drinks the cup of the Lord in an unworthy manner will be guilty concerning the body and blood of the Lord. Let a person examine himself, then, and so eat of the bread and drink of the cup. For anyone who eats and drinks without discerning the body eats and drinks judgment on himself. (1 Corinthians 11:27-29)

I see the Word EXAMINE in Scripture; and I see the Emphasis placed on self-examination (…I think that’s how Paul arrived at one of the most trustworthy and mature moments of his earthly existence – – – > 1 Tim. 1:15).
I don’t see the word presume or assume (at least I’m not finding it used in any Positive or Primary sort of way).
If anything I sense the danger of apostasy lurking behind the facade of presumption (1 Jn. 2:19).